The Injustice of Standardized Tests

Dylan Shapiro, Writer

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






Recently, the middle school finished taking their PSSAs, and Keystones began today. It is this time of the year, then, that people are noticing the unfairness of these tests. The questions are written in such a convoluted way, that sometimes these tests seem more like a logic puzzle than a fair assessment. It makes no sense why a test would have questions on it that are so unclear that students fail not because of lack of knowledge in the subject, but because they couldn’t understand the questions.

Standardized tests do not accurately show data, as demonstrated by a very simple scientific idea. For an experiment to be accurate and controlled, all variables, except the one you are testing for, must remain the same. Since the tests vary annually, they can’t accurately show growth, since students are taking different assessments each year. It appears that the state that approved this test didn’t pass fifth grade science.

These test are also unreasonably long. Students spend a minimum of five days testing for the PSSAs, and at least seven for the Keystones combined throughout their academic careers. That is outrageous and expensive, because it costs the district money to buy these tests to give to students. Again, it makes no sense why the district would force a kid to take a test they don’t want to take, for an unnecessarily long time, which costs the district more money in testing resources and administration. There is not a single positive in this situation, but it’s how the system works.

These test scores are also used to discredit teachers, simply because of something that is out of their control. If a math teacher tries to teach a kid math, and the kid adamantly refuses to learn any math, and fails their test, how is that the teacher’s fault? Now, if the district just gave the teachers a report on scores, this would be a relatively harmless, but sadly ineffective, PPS process. It is a far more serious problem, because these scores are a factor in teacher pay. Under the current system, students need a proficient to pass. Therefore, if a teacher brought a student up from a below basic to a basic, the student would still fail, and it would reflect poorly on the teacher. But if a different teacher has a student at the start of the year who began at a proficient, and ends on a proficient, that teacher would be rewarded. Since the test has only one benchmark, it doesn’t even show how much the student learned through the year. It makes the most sense to evaluate teachers based on how much a student learned, not how much they knew based off of an arbitrary standard.

I would recommend that three things happen. First, testing should be reduced to a day per subject. Second, the tests should only take place for an hour each day, not the entire morning. Third, tests should happen twice per school year, so they show growth, and lastly, eliminate the component of testing that affects teacher pay at all. These tests are a necessary evil, but they should be used to show students and teachers how much they have grown, not that they are permanently below average.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Navigate Right
Navigate Left
  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    A Recap of the Pittsburgh Primaries and What They Mean for Public Education

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    The Eagle Interviews Registered Nurse and Author Theresa Brown

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    Results Come in For Governor, U.S. Senate Primaries

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    We Interviewed Lindsey Williams, Democratic Candidate for Senate District 38

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    We Interviewed Stephanie Walsh, Democratic Candidate for Senate District 38

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    Obama Baseball Wraps Up Season

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    Kilauea: Hawaii Volcano Eruption

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    Discrimination Against LGBTQ+ Students in Schools

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    Obama Shoots Up In School Rankings

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    Senior of the Week: Hazel Rouse

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    Special Olympics Track and Field Returns

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    All You Need to Know About… Cinco de Mayo

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    Our Visit to the Andy Warhol Museum

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    A Recap of Model 2018!

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    Obama YAG Swears in 2018-19 Officers

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    Obama Takes Part in National Day of Silence

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    Holi and Nowruz

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    Who Should Replace Stephen Foster?

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    What Do We Celebrate?

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    Deliciously Cheap: LaScola’s

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    Senior of the Week: Isaac Winograd

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    Manchester Craftsman’s Guild Very Own- Jeff Guerrero, Part One

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    Obama Tenth Graders Make a Preschool Visit

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    A New Day for LGBTQ+ Youth in the Middle School

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    Councilwoman Erika Strassburger Speaks with the Eagle

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    A Call For Middle School Writers!

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    Pianist, Composer Douglas Levine Offers Master Class at Obama

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    State Representative Visits Obama

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    Senior of the Week: Bryn Young

  • The Injustice of Standardized Tests

    All Posts

    Potiguaya Comes to Pittsburgh

Pittsburgh Barack Obama Academy of International Studies
The Injustice of Standardized Tests