Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






The Last Presidential Debate- A glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

Listening to the Presidential Debate, I was impossibly disappointed. I had hoped, perhaps naively, to hear two well-educated, globally aware candidates debate foreign possibly. Instead, I was inundated with irrelevant, often unfounded rhetoric. I learned little about either beyond their desperation to pander to voters. Throughout it, the theme of “America is the best, and the savior of all” was predominant. THAT is exactly what is wrong with the United States today.
An aura of excessive pride was predominant, as was condescension. I was hugely dismayed by Mitt Romney’s early statement that the key to a peaceful world was “to get the Muslim world to be able to reject extremism on its own.” Does he really mean to insinuate that Islamic world, as a whole, embraces or passively accepts extremism. Well, since he doesn’t seem to know, I’ll tell you- it’s not true. Anyone who has payed attention to Pakistan recently can see that the majority of the civilians are moderate, rational people. They are rising up against the few bring violence in the name of religion. The majority of the Islamic World is comprised of moderate, peace loving people just like me or you. I know, I’ve met many of them. That Mitt Romney would look down and lay blame upon an entire religion for the very fringe extremists is a terrible injustice. It’s this heavy handed blame and ignorance that is the problem of America today.
The debate, as with the others, was littered with over simplifications and gaping holes in policy. I hope I wasn’t the only one who cringed when Romney said “my strategy’s pretty straightforward, which is to go after the bad guys.” No. This isn’t a comic book, Mr. Romney, and you certainly aren’t Superman. Nothing in life is can be broken down to black and white, and goodness knows, solutions to world problems are not simple. I cannot stand attempts to paint America as “good guys” and our enemies as “bad guys.” We are not “good.” America has done much wrong- torture, civilian casualties, support of oppressive regimes. The problem with America today is that nothing is that simple, and we try to make it be.
The candidates both spent much of the time bragging about, and planning to, kill, extra-judicially, enemies. Did it strike anyone else strange that this was considered one of the greatest accomplishments? Since when is killing someone something to aspire to? In one of the drone strikes targeting Al-Qaeda leaders, the 16 year old American citizen son of one leader was killed. This is a problem. Has the right to a trial been waived? Can the military now kill civilians on a whim? The fact the killing is seen as a cause for celebration is the problem of America today.
I’ve really begun to worry that neither candidate knows much about foreign policy. Mitt Romney said that he would indict Ahmadinejad on charges of genocide. No. Just no. Does he know what genocide is? You can indict Omar al-Bashir for ordering systematic scorched earth policy, rape, and mass murder in the Darfur region. You cannot indict Ahmadinejad for TALKING about wanting an end to the Israeli regime. A misdirection of priorities in our view of the world is a problem of America today.
The last, most general critique I have for the debate is this- the debate was not really about foreign policy. Rather than address real foreign policy issues, the candidates kept bringing it back to domestic policy and the economy. It seems, they don’t care about the state of the rest of the world- our money is more important. The only way, they seem to suggest, the world is important is the way it directly affects us, and especially our economy. That’s just wrong. This single-minded, nationalistic focus is the problem of America today.
Until this debate, I was feeling hesitantly optimistic that the country might be ok. Now, though, I’m rather dissapointed in both candidates. I’m not confident I can trust either to be a good voice of the USA to the rest of the world. Right now, we desperately need to make friends. Romney says Iran is the greatest threat to America, Obama says terrorism; I say it’s our condescending, self-centered attitude.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Navigate Left
  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Peabody Class of 1974 Visits Obama for 45th Reunion

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    The Problem with Dress Codes

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Obama Seniors on Their Last Year of High School

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    Creative Writing

    Hear Me Out

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Youth Participatory Budget Council Presents Proposal on Gentrification to City Council

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Obama Baseball Wins Walk-Off Thriller

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    UPMC-Highmark Consent Decree: Where We Stand

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Summer Lee Announces Police Reform Proposals in Response to Shootings, Protests

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Obama YAG Wins Big at Model Convention

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Senior of the week: Jason Thomas

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    A Day After Protests, Students Share Why They Didn’t Go

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Who Will be the Democratic Presidential Candidate in 2020?

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Michael Rosfeld’s Acquittal is Just Another in a Long Line of Abuses of Power

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Michael Rosfeld Acquitted on All Charges for the Killing of Antwon Rose II

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Senior of the Week: Mya Young

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    “Savior Samuel” Celebrates 15th Anniversary of Pittsburgh Playwrights Theater Company

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Dr. Knox and Mr. Mal

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Senior of the Week: Raven Haston

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Northside Chronicle Editor Ashlee Green on Hyper-Local Journalism

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    The Green Book

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Why Going BPA-Free Might Not Be As Great As You Think

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Senior of the Week Talaya Caldwell

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Responses to The Hate U Give

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Black Life

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Senior of the Week: Ava Eckenrode

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Senior of the Week: Ta’Shown Taylor

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Students Frustrated by New Bus Pass Failures

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    LeadYoung Initiative: Sophie Levitt

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Reflecting on the Life of Jonathan Freeman

  • Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States

    All Posts

    Author, Harvard Professor Jill Lepore on the Historical Record and the Direction of the Future

Navigate Right
Pittsburgh Barack Obama Academy of International Studies
Caley Donovan-The last presidential debate: a glimpse at what is wrong with the United States